Roof Repair, Restoration or Replacement?

Resources for Building Owners & Managers

The work your roof needs depends on its condition and what is causing the trouble.

A repair, a coating and a new roof are different ways of dealing with different problems. Here is what each option involves and what to ask the contractor inspecting your building, so you can understand the recommendation as well as the price.

Understand what each option changes

Ask the contractor which problems the proposed work will fix. A repair in one area, a roof coating and a new roof system do different jobs. Two proposals can have similar prices while removing, repairing or leaving very different parts of the roof in place.

Four roofing scopes at a glance
Option What the work does What the contractor needs to check
Repair Specific damage or problem areas on the existing roof. What caused the problem, how far the repair needs to extend and the condition of the material around it.
Coating restoration A compatible protective coating applied after the existing roof is repaired and prepared. The condition of the existing roof, needed repairs and whether the coating system is suitable for it.
Recover A new roofing system installed over an existing roof that stays in place. Whether existing materials can stay, how the new roof will be attached, added weight and applicable requirements.
Replacement Removing existing roofing and installing a new system in the agreed area. Which layers come off, which stay and how damage to the deck or other hidden materials will be handled.

Your contractor should explain which of these approaches fits each part of the roof. One section could need different work from another. Ask for a roof plan or marked photo showing where repairs, coating or replacement are proposed and how the sections will connect.

Ask what the recommendation is based on

  1. Find out what is wrong and how far it extends

    Ask the contractor to show you what was found and where. A recurring leak needs an explanation of how water is getting in. If work is recommended across the whole roof, ask what makes that necessary. The photos, previous repairs and inspection findings should help you understand why the proposed work is needed.

  2. Understand what stays in place

    For restoration or recover, ask which roof layers will stay and how the contractor checked them. Discuss any wet insulation, damage, loose material or drainage problems found. If the contractor cannot yet tell what is happening beneath the surface, ask what further checking is needed before the work can be planned.

  3. Ask how the work will fix the problems

    Have the contractor walk through how the proposal addresses each major problem. Repairs and preparation should be listed as part of the work, not left for you to assume they are included. When comparing options, make sure they cover the same roof area and account for the same existing damage.

You do not need to choose the testing equipment yourself. Ask what the contractor expects to learn and how that answer will affect the recommendation. If part of the roof needs to be opened, agree on who approves the work, who repairs the opening and what photos or notes you will receive afterward.

A coating begins with the roof beneath it

Choosing a coating is only part of planning a restoration. The contractor also needs to identify the existing material, check its condition and plan the repairs and preparation. The coating must be compatible with that surface and applied according to the requirements for the proposed system.

RCMA’s guidance on primers and roof preparation explains that the primer must suit both the roof surface and the coating manufacturer’s requirements. Primer does not take the place of cleaning or repairs. Ask for those tasks to be listed in the proposal so you know what will be done before coating begins.

Will the coating stick?

An adhesion test checks how well the coating bonds to the surface tested. Ask where the test was done and whether it used the coating and preparation planned for your roof.

What is under the surface?

The contractor also needs to check for wet materials, poor attachment and deteriorated layers below the surface. A roof that looks sound from above can still have problems underneath.

How will the details be handled?

Ask how the contractor will handle drains, edges, roof penetrations and places where materials meet. These areas need their own repair and installation details, beyond the coating applied to the open roof surface.

IIBEC’s substrate preparation discussion identifies both surface preparation and underlying substrate problems as important to coating performance. Choice’s earlier roof-restoration article provides additional background, while Why a Good Adhesion Test Isn’t Enough looks more closely at concealed-condition questions.

Plan around the people using the building

Tell the contractor what happens in the building each day and what cannot easily be interrupted. Discuss deliveries, entrances, tenant activities, equipment protection and working hours. Coating still requires preparation and suitable weather. Replacement also needs a plan for removing old roofing, protecting the building during the work and moving materials on and off the roof.

Ask what is included now and what maintenance or additional work will be needed later. If a repair is meant to buy time before a larger project, ask what it is expected to accomplish. If the recommendation is for more extensive work, ask how it will address the problems that have led to repeated repairs.

Read the warranty terms for each option. Material coverage and the contractor’s workmanship coverage can address different things. Along with the number of years, check what is covered, who handles a claim, how to report a problem and what maintenance is required. Those details help you understand what the warranty actually provides.

The estimate comparison guide helps you compare those details. For more about the work itself, see commercial roof repair and elastomeric coating systems. The recommendation and price should reflect your roof’s condition and the work included. The contractor should be able to explain why that approach fits your building.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does a leaking commercial roof need replacement?
Not always. The contractor needs to find the cause, check how far the damage extends and look at the rest of the roof. Those findings help determine whether a repair is enough or more extensive work is needed.

Can a roof coating be installed over wet insulation?
Coating the surface does not fix wet insulation underneath. The contractor needs to identify the affected materials and explain what must be removed or otherwise corrected before recommending restoration.

Is a successful adhesion test enough to approve restoration?
No. It tells you how well the coating bonds to the surface tested. The contractor still needs to evaluate the roof’s drainage, attachment and hidden layers before deciding whether restoration is suitable.

What is the difference between a recover and replacement?
A recover adds a new roofing system over an existing roof that is suitable to stay. Replacement involves removing existing roofing in the agreed area. Ask the contractor exactly which layers will stay or be removed and why that approach fits the roof and applicable requirements.

Talk with a contractor about your roof

Choice Roof Contractor Group helps building owners connect with independent roofing contractors. Your request can go to a member or non-member. The contractor will evaluate the building, explain the recommended work and provide the estimate and project terms.

Request a local estimate